You have come to the right hotel reservations website if you are looking for 3-star hotels for your next stay in Shelter Island Heights . We have wide selection of three star Shelter Island Heights hotels, motels & Inns, like Westbrook Inn Bed and Breakfast, Montauk Manor and Captain Stannard Bed and Breakfast Country Inn. Read customer reviews and find deeply discounted room rates on three star hotels in Shelter Island Heights. Select from available room types at these hotels, motels and inns like standard king bed or double queen beds or suites. With amenities like Hair Dryer, Free Early Check-in and Coffeemaker. These three star properties have a good balance on cost and comfort.